Cybersecurity ROI: How It Saves You Money

"Security is just a cost center."

I hear this from business owners all the time. But when you look at the numbers, cybersecurity investments often deliver substantial returns. Here's how to think about it.

The Cost of NOT Investing

Direct Breach Costs

• Average SMB breach cost: $108,000 - $200,000+
• Average ransomware payment: $170,000 (SMB)
• Incident response: $10,000 - $50,000+
• Legal fees: $10,000 - $100,000+
• Regulatory fines: Varies (HIPAA: up to $1.5M per incident)

Indirect Costs

• Downtime: Average 21 days for ransomware
• Lost revenue: $8,000-$74,000 per hour (depending on business size)
• Customer churn: 22% of customers leave after a breach
• Reputation damage: Difficult to quantify, but devastating
• Increased insurance premiums: 25-100% increase post-breach

Calculating Security ROI

The Basic Formula

ROI = (Risk Reduction - Security Investment) / Security Investment × 100

Example Calculation

Scenario: A medical practice considering MFA implementation

Without MFA:

• Probability of email compromise: 20% annually
• Potential cost of compromise: $150,000
• Expected annual loss: $30,000 (20% × $150,000)

With MFA:

• Cost of implementation: $2,000
• New probability of compromise: 2% annually
• Expected annual loss: $3,000 (2% × $150,000)

ROI Calculation:

• Risk reduction: $30,000 - $3,000 = $27,000
• Net benefit: $27,000 - $2,000 = $25,000
• ROI: ($25,000 / $2,000) × 100 = 1,250% ROI

High-ROI Security Investments

1. Multi-Factor Authentication

• Cost: $0-50/user/year
• Risk reduction: 99.9% of account compromise attacks
• ROI: 1,000%+

2. Security Awareness Training

• Cost: $15-50/user/year
• Risk reduction: 45-70% fewer successful phishing attacks
• ROI: 500%+

3. Backup and Recovery

• Cost: $100-500/month
• Risk reduction: Complete ransomware recovery without payment
• ROI: 1,000%+ (if you'd otherwise pay ransom)

4. Patch Management

• Cost: Staff time + tools ($100-500/month)
• Risk reduction: Prevents 60% of breaches
• ROI: 400%+

5. Penetration Testing

• Cost: $5,000-20,000/year
• Risk reduction: Identifies vulnerabilities before attackers
• ROI: 200-500%

Beyond Financial ROI

Business Enablement

Good security enables you to:

• Win contracts requiring security certifications
• Work with larger clients with vendor requirements
• Enter regulated industries
• Process credit cards (PCI compliance)

Competitive Advantage

Security can differentiate you:

• "We take your data seriously"
• SOC 2, ISO 27001 certifications
• Security as a selling point

Insurance Savings

Strong security posture leads to:

• Lower cyber insurance premiums (10-30%)
• Better coverage terms
• Easier claims process

Building the Business Case

Step 1: Identify Your Risks

• What data do you have?
• What systems are critical?
• What would downtime cost?

Step 2: Quantify Potential Losses

• Research industry breach costs
• Calculate your downtime cost
• Consider regulatory implications

Step 3: Evaluate Security Investments

• What controls address your top risks?
• What do they cost?
• What risk reduction do they provide?

Step 4: Calculate ROI

• Use the formula above
• Present in business terms
• Compare to other investments

Talking to Leadership

Frame It as Risk Management

"We're not buying security products; we're reducing business risk."

Use Business Language

Instead of: "We need a next-gen firewall with ATP" Say: "We need to protect against ransomware that could shut us down for 3 weeks"

Compare to Insurance

"You pay for fire insurance hoping you never use it. Cybersecurity is similar, but it actively prevents fires."

Show the Alternatives

"We can invest $20,000 in prevention or risk $200,000 in breach costs. Which makes more sense?"

The Bottom Line

Security isn't just about preventing bad things—it's about enabling good things:

• Protecting revenue
• Building customer trust
• Enabling business growth
• Reducing long-term costs

When you calculate the full picture, security investments often deliver better ROI than traditional business investments.

---

Want help building a security business case? Contact us: m1k3@msquarellc.net