Whitepaper: Red Team vs. Blue Team — Why SMBs Need Both

Executive Summary

The terms "red team" and "blue team" originated in military exercises and have become fundamental concepts in cybersecurity. While enterprise organizations have dedicated teams for both functions, small and medium businesses often believe these capabilities are out of reach.

This whitepaper explains both concepts and provides practical guidance on how SMBs can benefit from red and blue team activities without enterprise-level budgets.

Understanding the Teams

Red Team: The Attackers

Mission: Simulate real-world attacks to identify vulnerabilities and test defenses.

Activities:

• Penetration testing
• Social engineering
• Physical security testing
• Adversary simulation
• Security control bypass

Mindset: "How can I break in?"

Blue Team: The Defenders

Mission: Protect systems, detect threats, and respond to incidents.

Activities:

• Security monitoring
• Incident detection and response
• Threat hunting
• Security hardening
• Vulnerability management

Mindset: "How can I keep attackers out and detect them if they get in?"

Purple Team: The Collaboration

Mission: Improve security through collaboration between red and blue.

Activities:

• Sharing attack techniques with defenders
• Testing detection capabilities
• Closing gaps identified through exercises
• Continuous improvement

Mindset: "How can we learn from each other?"

Why SMBs Need Offensive Security (Red Team)

The Reality Check

Without testing, you don't know:

• If your firewall is actually blocking attacks
• Whether employees will click phishing links
• If your systems are properly patched
• What attackers see when they target you

Benefits for SMBs

1. Find Vulnerabilities Before Attackers Do A penetration test reveals weaknesses that automated scans miss.

2. Validate Security Investments That expensive firewall? Testing confirms it's actually protecting you.

3. Meet Compliance Requirements Many regulations require regular security testing.

4. Prioritize Remediation Limited budgets mean you need to fix the most critical issues first.

SMB-Appropriate Red Team Activities

Activity	Frequency	Typical Cost
External Penetration Test	Annual	$5,000-$15,000
Internal Penetration Test	Annual	$8,000-$20,000
Phishing Simulation	Monthly/Quarterly	$500-$2,000
Web Application Test	Per major release	$5,000-$15,000
Wireless Assessment	Annual	$2,000-$5,000

Why SMBs Need Defensive Security (Blue Team)

The Reality Check

Without monitoring, you won't know:

• When attackers are in your network
• If credentials have been compromised
• Whether malware is spreading
• How long until you detect a breach

Average time to detect a breach: 197 days

Benefits for SMBs

1. Early Detection Catching attacks early dramatically reduces damage.

2. Incident Response Capability Knowing what to do when something happens.

3. Compliance Evidence Logging and monitoring meet regulatory requirements.

4. Continuous Protection Unlike point-in-time testing, monitoring is ongoing.

SMB-Appropriate Blue Team Activities

Activity	Implementation	Typical Cost
EDR Deployment	All endpoints	$3-$8/endpoint/month
Log Management	Centralized logging	$500-$2,000/month
Managed Detection	24/7 monitoring	$2,000-$5,000/month
Vulnerability Scanning	Weekly/monthly	$100-$500/month
Security Awareness	Ongoing	$2-$5/user/month

The SMB Approach: Right-Sizing Red and Blue

Tier 1: Essential (Budget: $10,000-$25,000/year)

Red Team:

• Annual external penetration test
• Quarterly phishing simulations

Blue Team:

• EDR on all endpoints
• Basic log retention
• Automated vulnerability scanning

Gap: Limited detection capability, no 24/7 monitoring

Tier 2: Maturing (Budget: $25,000-$75,000/year)

Red Team:

• External and internal penetration testing
• Monthly phishing simulations
• Web application testing

Blue Team:

• EDR with managed monitoring
• SIEM or log management platform
• Incident response plan
• Regular vulnerability management

Gap: Limited threat hunting, reactive posture

Tier 3: Advanced (Budget: $75,000-$150,000/year)

Red Team:

• Comprehensive penetration testing
• Red team exercises (multi-vector)
• Continuous phishing assessment
• Physical security testing

Blue Team:

• 24/7 managed detection and response
• Threat hunting
• Mature incident response
• Security orchestration

Benefit: Proactive security posture, rapid detection and response

Building Your Program

Phase 1: Foundation (Months 1-3)

Assess Current State:

• Inventory assets
• Identify critical data
• Review existing controls
• Understand compliance requirements

Quick Wins:

• Enable MFA everywhere
• Deploy EDR
• Implement basic monitoring
• Conduct baseline vulnerability scan

Phase 2: Testing (Months 3-6)

Red Team Activity:

• External penetration test
• Phishing assessment

Blue Team Response:

• Remediate findings
• Tune detection rules
• Update procedures

Phase 3: Maturation (Months 6-12)

Red Team Activity:

• Internal testing
• Expanded phishing program
• Social engineering tests

Blue Team Development:

• Enhanced monitoring
• Incident response procedures
• Regular tabletop exercises

Phase 4: Continuous Improvement (Ongoing)

Purple Team Integration:

• Share findings between functions
• Test detection against known techniques
• Measure improvement over time

Metrics That Matter

Red Team Metrics

• Vulnerabilities found per test
• Time to compromise
• Successful social engineering rate
• Critical findings remediated

Blue Team Metrics

• Mean time to detect (MTTD)
• Mean time to respond (MTTR)
• Alert volume and false positive rate
• Security coverage percentage

Combined Metrics

• Detection rate of red team activities
• Improvement between assessments
• Risk reduction over time

Common Mistakes

Red Team Mistakes

• Testing without clear scope
• Not testing internal threats
• Ignoring social engineering
• No remediation follow-up

Blue Team Mistakes

• Alert fatigue (too many alerts, not enough analysis)
• No incident response plan
• Logs without review
• Assuming tools = security

Strategic Mistakes

• Red without blue (finding issues but not detecting attacks)
• Blue without red (defending but never testing)
• One-time effort (security is ongoing)

Conclusion

SMBs don't need dedicated red and blue teams, but they do need both offensive and defensive security capabilities. The key is right-sizing these activities to your organization's risk profile and budget.

Key Takeaways:

1. Start with defense — Detection and response are always-on needs
2. Add offense annually — Penetration testing validates your defenses
3. Build toward purple — Integrate findings to improve continuously
4. Scale over time — Mature your program as resources allow

The goal isn't to match enterprise programs—it's to achieve appropriate security for your risk level and resources.

---

Need help building your security program? Contact us: m1k3@msquarellc.net